Medical Record Review Standards

Purpose: The Medical Record Standards provide instructions, rules, regulations, parameters, and indicators for conducting medical record reviews using the Medical Record Review Tool. The site reviewer must use these Standards for measuring, evaluating, assessing, and making decisions. 

Medical Record Selection: Medical records shall be randomly selected using methodology decided upon by the reviewer. Ten (10) medical records are reviewed for each PCP site. For sites with only adult or only pediatric patient members, all ten records reviewed will be in only one preventive care criteria. For sites with adult and pediatric members, five (5) adults and five (5) pediatrics preventive criteria will be reviewed. For PCP sites where the OB-GYN providers both specialty and preventive services, based on the age of the patient, reviewer must review either adult or pediatric preventive criteria as well as OB CPSP criteria. 

PCP sites that document patient care performed by multiple PCPs in the same medical record are considered “shared.” The MCP must consider shared medical records as those that are not identifiable as “separate” records belonging to any specific PCP. Scores calculated on shared medical records apply only to PCPs sharing the records. A minimum of ten shared records shall be reviewed for 2-3 PCPs, 20 records for 4-6 PCPs, and 30 records for 7 or more PCPs based on specialty and/or population served. 

Example for determining the number of medical records to review: 

A site that has three (3 ) providers, two (2) providers see only adults and share records, and one (1) only see pediatrics and does not share records, 10 medical records on the two providers who share medical records and 10 medical records on the provider who does not share records will be conducted and scored separately. A total of 20 medical records shall be reviewed for this site. Two (2) scores will be reported for this site. 

Reviewers are expected to determine the most appropriate method(s) on each site to ascertain information needed to complete the review. Review criteria to be reviewed only by a registered nurse (RN), nurse practitioner (NP), physician (MD), or physician assistant (PA) is labeled “ RN/NP/MD/PA”. 

Reviewers must ensure confidentiality on Protected Health Information (PHI) or Personally Identifiable Information (PII). 

Scoring: The review score is based on a review standard of 10 records per individual primary care provider (PCP). Documented evidence found in the hard copy (paper) medical records and/or electronic medical records, including immunization registries, are used for review criteria determinations. Compliance levels are: 

An Exempted Pass is 90%. 

Conditional Pass is 80-89%. 

Failure is below 80%. 

The minimum passing score is 80%. A corrective action plan (CAP) is required for a total MRR score below 90%. Also, any section score of less than 80% requires a CAP for the entire MRR, regardless of the total MRR score. 

Not Applicable (N/A) applies to any criterion that does not apply to the medical record being reviewed and must be explained in the comment section. 

Directions: Score one point if criterion is met. Score zero points if criterion is not met. Do not score partial points for any criterion. 

If 10 shared records are reviewed, score calculation shall be the same as for 10 records reviewed for a single PCP. 

If 20 records are reviewed, divide total points given by the “adjusted” total points possible. 

If 30 records are reviewed, divide total points given by the “adjusted” total points possible. 

Multiply by 100 to calculate percentage rate. 

Reviewers have the option to request additional records to review but must calculate scores accordingly. 

Scoring Example: 

Step 1: Add the points given in each section. 

Step 2: Add the points given for all six sections. 

(Format points given) 

(Documentation points given) 

(Coordination/Continuity of Care points given) 

(Pediatric Preventive points given) 

(Adult Preventive points given) 

+ (OB/CPSP Preventive points given) 

= (Total points given) 

Step 3: Subtract the “N/A” points from total points possible. 

(Total points possible) 

Revision Draft 7/27/21 TC – MCP Collaborative Feedback 3 

– (N/A points) 

= (“Adjusted” total points possible) 

Step 4: Divide total points given by the “adjusted” points possible, then multiply by 100 to calculate percentage rate. 

Total points given Example: 267 

“Adjusted” total point’s possible 305 = 0.875 X 100 = 88% 

Rationale: A well-organized medical record keeping system supports effective patient care, information confidentiality and quality review processes.

Format Criteria

An individual medical record is established for each member.

Practitioners are able to readily identify each individual treated. A medical record is started upon the initial visit. “Family charts” are not acceptable. 

https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/laws-regulations/index.html

Member identification is on each page.

Member identification includes first and last name, and/or a unique identifier established for use on clinical site. 

Electronically maintained records and printed records from electronic systems must contain member identification.]

Individual personal biographical information is documented.

Personal biographical information includes: 

o Date of birth 

o Current address 

o Home/work phone numbers 

o Name of parent(s) /legal guardian if member is a minor 

If member refused to provide information, “refused” is documented in the medical record. Do not deduct points if member has refused to provide all personal information requested by the practitioner.

Emergency “contact” is identified.

The name and phone number of an “emergency contact” person is identified for all members. Listed emergency contacts may include: 

o Spouse, relative or friend, 

and must include at least one of the following: 

o Home, work, pager, cellular or message phone number 

• If the member is a minor, the primary (first) emergency contact person must be a parent or legal guardian and then other persons may be listed as additional emergency contacts 

• Adults and emancipated minors may list anyone of their choosing. Next of kin category is not considered as an emergency contact. The member’s emergency contact may be different from the next of kin 

• If a member refuses to provide an emergency contact, “refused” is noted in the record. Do not deduct points if member has refused to provide personal information requested by the practitioner.

Medical records are maintained and organized

Contents and format of printed and/or electronic records within the practice site are uniformly organized, securely fastened, attached or bound to prevent medical record loss. Hard copy printed documents shall belong to the medical record established for each member. (For example, reusing the blank side of printed documents from another member is not acceptable and should be scored a “0”.) Medical Record information should be readily available.

Member’s assigned and/or rendering primary care physician (PCP) is identified.

The assigned and/or rendering PCP is always identified when there is more than one PCP on site and/or when the member has selected health care from a non-physician medical practitioner. Since various methods are used to identify the assigned PCP, reviewers must identify specific method(s) used at each individual site such as Health Plan ID Card, practitioner stamp, etc. 

If there is only one PCP/Practitioner onsite and is N/A.

Primary language and linguistic service needs of non-or of limited-English proficiency (LEP) or hearing/speech-impaired persons are prominently noted.

The primary language is prominently documented at least once in the medical record. Language documentation is not necessary, score “N/A,” if English is the primary language. However, if “English” is documented, the point may be given. 

Note: Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits recipients of federal funds from providing services to LEP persons that are limited in scope or lower in quality than those provided to others. Since Medi-Cal is partially funded by federal funds, all Plans with Medi-Cal LEP members must ensure that these members have equal access to all health care services (DHCS All Plan Letter 17 – 011).

Person or entity providing medical interpretation is identified.

Requests for language and/or interpretation services by a non-or limited-English proficient member are documented. Member refusal of interpreter services may be documented at least once and be accepted throughout the member’s care unless otherwise specified. 

Note: https://www.lep.gov/faqs/faqs.html#OneQ11; 22CCR Section 51309.5 

• If bilingual staff are asked to interpret or translate, they should be qualified to do so. Assessment of ability, training on interpreter ethics and standards, and clear policies that delineate appropriate use of bilingual staff, staff or contract interpreters

• Those utilizing the services of interpreters and translators should request information about certification, assessments taken, qualifications, experience, and training. Quality of interpretation should be a focus of concern for all recipients 

• Family or friends should not be used as interpreters, unless specifically requested by the member and documented in the member’s chart 

• ACA 2010 section 1557: prohibits from using low-quality video remote interpreting services or relying on unqualified staff, translators when providing language assistance services 

• Sign language interpreter services may be utilized for medically necessary health care services and related services such as obtaining medical history and health assessments, obtaining informed consents and permission for treatments, medical procedures, providing instructions regarding medications, explaining diagnoses, treatment and prognoses of an illness, providing mental health assessment, therapy or counseling 

Various documents can be accepted to document linguistic service needs such as IHEBA/SHA, intake form, demographic form, EMR fields, consent forms, etc. All medical record documentation must be in English (ACA 2010 §1557).

Signed Copy of the Notice of Privacy

The HIPAA Privacy Rule establishes national standards to protect individuals’ medical records and other personal health information and applies to health plans, health care clearinghouses, and those health care providers that conduct certain health care transactions electronically. The right to inspect, review and receive a copy of the medical records is covered by the Privacy Rule. 

https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/guidance/permitted-uses/index.html

Rationale: Well-documented records facilitate communication and coordination and promote efficiency and effectiveness of treatment. 

Documentation Criteria

Allergies are prominently noted.

Allergies and adverse reactions are listed in a prominent, easily identified and consistent location in the medical record. If member has no allergies or adverse reactions, “No Known Allergies” (NKA), “No known Drug Allergies” (NKDA), or ∅ is documented. (22 CCR Section 70527, 28 CCR Section 1300.80)

Chronic problems and/or significant conditions are listed.

Documentation may be on a separate “problem list,” or a clearly identifiable problem list in the progress notes. All chronic or significant problems are considered current if no “end date” is documented. 

Note: Chronic conditions are current long-term, on-going conditions with slow or little progress. (22 CCR Section 70527, 28 CCR Section 1300.80)

Current continuous medications are listed.

Documentation may be on a separate “medication list,” or a clearly identifiable medication list in the progress notes. List of current, on-going medications identifies the medication name, strength, dosage, route (if other than oral), and frequency. Discontinued medications are noted on the medication list or in progress notes. (22 CCR Section 70527, 28 CCR Section 1300.80)

Appropriate Consents are present.

Providers must obtain voluntary written consent prior to examination and treatment, with appropriate regard to the patient’s age and following State and Federal laws. Consent also must be obtained prior to release of patient information. (22 CCR Section 73524; 45 CFR Section 164.524; 22 CCR Section 51009) 

Adults, parents/legal guardians of a minor or emancipated minors may sign consent forms for operative and invasive procedures.* Persons under 18 years of age are emancipated if they have entered into a valid marriage, are on military active duty, or have received a court declaration of emancipation under the CA Family Code, Section 7122. 

Note: Human sterilization requires DHCS Consent Form PM 330 if services are performed at the site.

* An invasive procedure is a medical procedure that invades (enters) the body, usually by cutting or puncturing the skin or by inserting instruments into the body. Very minor procedures such as drawing blood testing, umbilical cord blood donations and a few other very specific tests are not considered invasive and do not require a consent. 

Consent is implied by entering the provider’s office or lab and allowing blood to be drawn. (Ref: National Institutes of Health; American Cancer Society).

Advance Health Care Directive information is offered. (Adults 18 years or age or older; emancipated minors)

Adult medical records include documentation of whether the member has been offered information or has executed an Advance Health Care Directive (California Probate Code, Sections 4701; 42 CFR 422.128:42 CFR 489.100, APL 05010). 

The Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment (POLST) form and Five Wishes are acceptable if appropriately completed and signed by necessary parties. (Assembly Bill No.3000 Chapter 266) 

Note: Advance Health Care Directive Information is reviewed with the member at least every 5 years and as appropriate to the member’s circumstance.

All entries are signed, dated and legible.

Signature includes: 

o First initial, last name and title of health care personnel providing care, including Medical Assistants 

o Initials and titles may be used only if signatures are specifically identified elsewhere in the medical record (e.g. signature page) 

o Stamped signatures are acceptable, but must be authenticated, meaning the stamped signature can be verified, validated, confirmed, and is countersigned or initialed 

Dated entries include: 

o Month/day/year 

o Entries are in reasonably consecutive order by date 

o Handwritten documentation does not contain skipped lines or empty spaces where information can be added. Entries are not backdated or inserted into spaces above previous entries. 

o Omissions are charted as a new entry 

o Late entries are explained in the medical record, signed and dated

Legibility means the record entry is readable by a person other than the writer. Handwritten documentation, signatures and initials are entered in ink that can be readily/clearly copied. Only standard abbreviations are used. 

Note: 

• In electronic medical records (EMR), methods to document signatures (and/or authenticate initials) will vary and must be individually evaluated 

• Signature page may be in the member’s medical record or available elsewhere onsite and all previous and current employees who document in medical records need to be included on the signature page 

• Reviewers should assess the log-in process and may need to request printouts of entries 

https://www.cms.gov/Medicare-Medicaid-Coordination/Fraud-Prevention/Medicaid-Integrity-Education/Downloads/docmatters-officestaff-factsheet.pdf